Cold Call vs Cold Email: Understanding the Basics

In today’s highly competitive business landscape, effective sales outreach can make all the difference in achieving your goals. Two popular methods that sales professionals rely on are cold calling and cold emailing.

These approaches, although distinct in their execution, share a common goal: to engage with potential prospects and turn them into valuable customers.

In this article, we will delve into the fundamentals of cold calling and cold emailing, unraveling their intricacies and highlighting the unique advantages they offer.

Mailarrow Logo
Send cold emails that get responses
Start Free Trial

By gaining a comprehensive understanding of these techniques, you’ll be equipped with the knowledge to optimize your outreach strategy and enhance your sales success.

So, get ready to unlock the secrets behind successful sales outreach as we embark on this enlightening journey together!

The Art of Cold Calling

Cold calling has been a staple in the sales process for decades. It refers to the act of a sales rep initiating a phone call to potential customers without prior contact.

Often used to deliver a sales pitch, cold calling is a traditional sales technique that focuses on establishing a one-on-one conversation with potential clients.

Sales reps often adopt cold calling as their preferred outreach method due to its directness. It’s one of the few outreach methods that allow sales teams to initiate conversations, assess potential customer needs, and adjust their sales pitch in real-time.

This immediate response can be beneficial, especially when targeting higher-level prospects like C-level executives who value personal interactions.

However, as time-efficient as it may seem, cold calling is notoriously time-consuming. It requires obtaining phone numbers, dealing with gatekeepers, handling objections, and, most importantly, calling prospects multiple times until you get through.

Moreover, cold calling is not immune to a bad reputation. The traditional cold calls can often be seen as intrusive and can lead to negative impressions of your company if not handled correctly.

It’s crucial to understand that cold calling is a skill that requires excellent closing skills, good timing, and in-depth knowledge of the buyer persona.

Cold Emailing: A Modern Approach

In contrast, cold emailing represents a more modern approach to cold outreach efforts. Cold emails are unsolicited emails sent to potential customers without any prior contact.

Cold emailing sales emails is an effective sales prospecting method that has gained popularity among sales reps for several reasons.

Mailarrow Logo
Send cold emails that get responses
Start Free Trial

One major advantage of cold emailing over cold calling is its scalability. Cold email campaigns can be sent to a large target audience in a fraction of the time it takes to make sales calls.

Additionally, with the right software like Mailarrow, personalized cold emails can be sent en masse, ensuring that your message reaches the prospect’s inbox.

Another significant advantage of cold emailing is the ability to tailor your message to the buyer persona.

This includes creating good email subject lines, crafting a persuasive body, and using relevant data to make your argument more convincing.

However, as with any outreach strategy, cold emailing has its challenges. Getting your emails to land in your prospect’s inbox instead of the spam folder can be tricky.

Furthermore, gaining the prospect’s attention in an inbox full of sales emails can also be a daunting task.

In the battle of cold call vs cold email, it’s essential to consider these factors and understand how each method fits into your sales process. We will dive deeper into this subject, exploring more about the pros and cons of cold calling prospects vs cold emailing.

Stay tuned for more insights and remember, cold outreach is an art that requires a balance of technique, timing, and a deep understanding of your potential customer.

Let’s journey together in refining your cold outreach campaign strategy and boost your sales efforts. And don’t forget, Mailarrow, our cold email outreach software, is here to make your cold email campaigns a breeze.

The Pros and Cons of Cold Calling vs Cold Emailing

Delving Deeper into Cold Calling

When considering the cold email vs. calling vs cold emailing, one must weigh the advantages and drawbacks of each.

Cold Calling Pros

Cold calling, despite its reputation, holds some unique benefits. First, it provides immediate feedback. Unlike cold emails, where a response might take hours or even days, phone calls can result in an immediate response.

This direct response can give sales reps valuable insights into the potential customer’s needs, objections, and buying behavior.

Second, cold calls have a more personal tone. Despite being unsolicited, phone calls allow for a one-on-one conversation with the potential customer.

This personal interaction can help establish a relationship, understanding the client’s needs better, and tailor the sales pitch accordingly.

Cold Calling Cons

However, cold calling also comes with significant challenges. As mentioned earlier, it’s time-consuming. Sales reps can spend entire days making sales calls with minimal results.

Mailarrow Logo
Send cold emails that get responses
Start Free Trial

It’s also worth mentioning that phone connect rates have been dropping over the years, making cold calling less efficient.

Moreover, cold calling can be intrusive. Potential customers often see unsolicited phone calls as an invasion of their personal time. This bad reputation can have a negative impact on your company’s image.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Cold Emailing

Just like cold calling, cold emailing has its pros and cons.

Cold Emailing Pros

Cold emailing allows you to reach a broader target audience in a shorter time. Thanks to automation tools like Mailarrow, sales reps can send personalized cold emails to hundreds, if not thousands, of prospects simultaneously.

Moreover, cold emails can be carefully crafted to resonate with the buyer persona. With compelling subject lines and persuasive language, cold emails can grab the prospects attention, enticing them to read and respond.

Furthermore, cold emailing gives the recipient the flexibility to respond at their convenience, respecting the prospect’s time.

Cold Emailing Cons

On the downside, cold emailing faces the challenge of low open rates. If the cold emails land in the spam folder, or if the subject line doesn’t compel the prospect to open the email, your outreach efforts might go unnoticed.

Also, cold emails lack the personal touch of a phone call. While you can personalize your emails, it’s hard to replicate the connection built through a direct, one-on-one conversation.

Remember, the choice between cold calling and cold emailing largely depends on your target audience, resources, and sales strategy. In the following sections, we’ll take a closer look at how to choose between the two and how to effectively combine these outreach methods for maximum results. And remember, Mailarrow is here to help optimize your cold calling pros and emailing efforts.

Choosing the Right Approach: Cold Call, Cold Email, or Both?

Now that we’ve thoroughly examined both cold calling and cold emailing, the question arises, should you cold call or cold emailing pros first? This isn’t a simple answer, as it largely depends on your sales strategy, your target audience, and the nature of your product or service.

Cold Call, Email, or Both?

The decision between making a cold call or sending a cold email isn’t necessarily an “either-or” situation. Often, the most effective outreach strategy involves using both cold calling and cold emailing in conjunction.

For instance, your sales team may decide to send a cold email introducing your product or service. This email serves to warm up the potential customer to your brand before a sales representative makes a follow-up call.

Alternatively, a sales rep might initiate contact with a cold call and then send a follow-up email summarizing the points discussed and providing further information.

Asian salesman in office making business phone call sitting at laptop computer

This combined approach ensures that you’re covering all your bases, reaching out to potential customers in various ways, and giving them multiple opportunities to engage with your brand.

However, this requires careful coordination and excellent timing. It’s crucial that your cold outreach efforts do not become spammy or too aggressive, which could deter potential customers.

Mailarrow Logo
Send cold emails that get responses
Start Free Trial

Understanding Your Audience

Understanding your target audience is vital in deciding whether to use a cold call, a cold email, or both. Some people prefer phone calls and appreciate the personal touch they provide. Others might consider unsolicited phone calls disruptive and prefer to communicate via email.

Researching your buyer persona will give you gain valuable insights into their communication preferences. For example, busy C-level executives might prefer a succinct email they can read at their leisure, whereas a manager might appreciate the immediacy of a phone call.

Considering Your Product or Service

The nature of your product or service can also determine whether a cold call or a cold email is more appropriate.

Complex products or services that require a detailed explanation might be better suited to a phone call, where a sales representative can thoroughly explain the product, answer questions, and handle objections.

On the other hand, simple products or services that can be easily understood from an email might not require a phone call. A well-crafted email with a compelling call to action might be sufficient.

Ultimately, the decision between cold calling and cold emailing or using both methods should be data-driven. Keep track of your success rates with each method, analyze the results, and adjust your strategy accordingly.

Remember, Mailarrow is here to help streamline your cold email outreach efforts with its robust and intuitive platform. Don’t forget to sign up!

Strategies for Effective Cold Calling and Cold Emailing

Given the primary differences between cold calling and cold emailing, effective strategies need to be employed for each outreach method. The right approach can boost your lead generation and sales prospecting results significantly.

Strategies for Effective Cold Calling

The success of cold calls heavily relies on the skills of the sales rep, the timing of the cold calls, and the quality of the sales pitch. Here are some strategies to make your cold calls more effective:

  1. Research before calling: Knowing your prospect can make the conversation more meaningful. Understand the prospect’s industry, role, and potential challenges. This allows you to tailor your sales pitch to their needs and interests.
  2. Perfect your opening: The first few seconds of a call determine if the potential customer will hang up or continue the conversation. Make sure your opening is engaging and creates curiosity.
  3. Choose the right time: Phone calls can be disruptive, so timing is crucial. Research suggests that the best time to make a sales call is in the mid-to-late afternoon, as the week progresses.
  4. Practice active listening: Active listening helps in understanding the prospect’s needs better and also shows respect, which can foster a better relationship.
  5. Follow-up: Cold calling typically requires several follow-ups before you can close a deal. Be persistent, but not annoying.

Strategies for Effective Cold Emailing

With cold emails, the challenge is to stand out in a crowded inbox and compel the recipient to take action. Here are some strategies to make your cold emails more effective:

  1. Personalization: Personalized cold emails are more likely to get opened, read, and responded to. Tailor your emails based on the recipient’s industry, role, and potential pain points.
  2. Compelling Subject Line: The subject line is the first thing a prospect sees. It should be compelling enough to prompt the recipient to open the email.
  3. Clear and Concise: Keep your email short, simple, and to the point. Long emails are likely to be ignored or quickly skimmed over.
  4. Call to Action: The purpose of your email should be clear. Make sure your call to action is prominent and compelling.
  5. Follow-up: Much like cold calling, follow-up is key in cold emailing. If you don’t get a response, don’t be afraid to follow up. But remember, persistence should not cross over into spam.

No matter what outreach method you decide on, remember that consistency is key. Regular, persistent outreach efforts can help keep you top of mind with potential customers and increase your chances of success.

Be sure to leverage a tool like Mailarrow to streamline and optimize your cold email outreach.

Overcoming Challenges in Cold Calling and Cold Emailing

Overcoming Cold Calling Challenges

Despite the potential benefits of cold calling, sales reps face several challenges. A common issue is the difficulty in getting through to the right person. Gatekeepers, such as receptionists or assistants, can be adept at blocking sales calls.

This is such an approach where relevant data about the organization and the individual can help you navigate through to the right person.

Another challenge is the declining phone connect rates. This is often because most people do not answer calls from unknown numbers. Overcoming this requires persistence, creativity, and occasionally, the use of alternative methods such as cold emailing.

Mailarrow Logo
Send cold emails that get responses
Start Free Trial

Lastly, the potential for immediate rejection can be high in cold calling. Sales reps need to be prepared to handle objections and continue the conversation in a professional and friendly manner. This is where superior closing skills can make a significant difference.

Overcoming Cold Emailing Challenges

One of the most significant challenges in cold emailing is getting your email seen in a crowded inbox. With the high volume of emails people receive daily, it’s easy for your message to get lost or ignored. This is where a compelling subject line, personalization, and an attractive preview text can make your email stand out.

Another challenge with cold emailing is the possibility of your email landing in the spam folder. This can happen if your email seems too promotional, contains spammy words, or if you’ve been sending a high volume of emails. Using a reliable email service, like Mailarrow, can help ensure your emails land in the prospect’s inbox rather than the spam folder.

Finally, it can be challenging to convey tone and intent in an email. Unlike a phone call, an email doesn’t allow for tone of voice or immediate clarification of misunderstandings. In this case, carefully crafting your message and using a more personal tone can help establish a connection with your prospect.

Despite these challenges, both cold calling and cold emailing can be highly effective methods for generating leads and closing sales when done right. It’s about understanding the strengths and limitations of each approach, then implementing them in a way that fits with your overall sales strategy.

As you plan your next cold outreach campaign, consider how Mailarrow can help streamline your cold calling cons emailing process, enhancing efficiency, and boosting results. Stay tuned for the final part of this series where we delve into the frequently asked questions around cold calling and cold emailing.

Conclusions and Key Takeaways

The debate of cold call vs cold email isn’t about one being superior to the other. Each has its place within a comprehensive sales strategy. Cold calling provides a more personal tone, immediate response, and the opportunity for a one-on-one conversation. Cold emailing, on the other hand, is time efficient, can be easily scaled, and allows prospects to respond at their convenience.

It’s important to remember that the choice between cold calling and cold emailing isn’t an either-or situation. Successful sales teams often use a mix of both to maximize their outreach efforts. The optimal mix, however, would depend on various factors including your target audience, the nature of your product or service, and your sales team’s resources and capabilities.

Another key takeaway is that no matter the outreach method, personalization and relevance are critical. Be it a cold call or a cold email, taking the time to understand your potential customer’s needs and tailoring your message accordingly can significantly improve your success rate.

Lastly, don’t forget that tools like Mailarrow can greatly enhance your cold email outreach efforts. From ensuring your emails land in the prospect’s inbox to providing the relevant data you need for personalization, Mailarrow has got you covered. Sign up for Mailarrow and start boosting your cold email outreach today!

In the next section, we will be answering some frequently asked questions around cold calling and traditional cold calls and emailing. These answers aim to provide further clarity and guidance as you develop your cold outreach strategy. Stay tuned!

Frequently Asked Questions

Is cold calling better than cold emailing?

Neither is inherently better than the other. Both cold calling and cold emailing have their pros and cons, and their effectiveness can vary depending on factors like your industry, target audience, and the nature of your offer. A combination of both can often be the most effective strategy.

Should I cold call or email first?

This depends on your target audience and the nature of your business. In general, cold emailing can be a less intrusive first step, allowing the recipient to respond at their convenience. If the cold email campaign doesn’t get a response, a follow-up call can sometimes be effective.

Is cold call email illegal?

Cold emailing isn’t illegal, but it is regulated. In many regions, businesses must comply with certain guidelines when sending unsolicited cold emails out. These often include things like not using deceptive subject lines, providing a clear way to opt out, and including your valid physical postal address.

Is it better to call or email clients?

It depends on the client’s preferences, the nature of the message, and the urgency of the communication. Some people prefer phone calls for their immediacy and personal touch, while others prefer emails because they’re less disruptive and allow for more thoughtful responses.

Mailarrow Logo
Send cold emails that get responses
Start Free Trial

Are cold emails better than cold calls?

Cold emails and cold calls serve different purposes and work better in different circumstances. Cold emails can reach a larger audience and are less intrusive, while cold calls can often lead to deeper, more immediate conversations.

Should you cold email or cold call first?

This depends on your business, your target audience, and the nature of your offer. However, starting with a cold email can be less intrusive and gives the recipient a chance to consider your proposition before you make contact through a call.

What is the cold call term for email?

The equivalent term for a cold call in email is a cold email. It refers both cold emails and to an unsolicited email sent to a potential customer with whom you have no prior contact.

What do you put in a cold call email?

A cold call email should include a compelling subject line, a personalized greeting, a brief introduction of who you are and what your business offers, a clear and relevant proposition, and a call to action.

Is it appropriate to cold email?

Yes, it’s appropriate to cold email as part of your sales and marketing efforts, but you must ensure you’re abiding by all relevant laws and regulations and respecting the recipient’s preferences.

Is it better to cold email or cold call?

The choice between cold email vs cold call, and cold call depends on various factors like your target audience, the nature of your product or service, and your sales strategy. A combination of both is often the most effective.

What’s more effective than cold calling?

In some cases, cold emailing can be more effective than cold calling. It’s scalable, less intrusive, and gives the recipient a chance to respond at their convenience. However, the effectiveness can vary greatly depending on your industry and target audience.

How do you send an email after a cold call?

After a cold call, it’s a good practice to send a follow-up email summarizing the conversation, reiterating the value proposition, and outlining the next steps. Be sure to personalize the email based on the conversation you had during the call.

Serge Shlykov is the founder of Mailarrow. Rotterdam Business School graduate and a long-time software engineer he has been running his own agency and SaaS business before realizing how many people are struggling with cold email outreach. This made him create Mailarrow, the cold email outreach software that helps you build great relationships at scale. Find him on Twitter and LinkedIn